Re-examining My Previous Sketch

Added some info on how I see mutualism benefiting both new and old structures.  Hope it helps to explain what I am trying to accomplish.

So Abstract it is Concrete...

Here is iteration number 1.5 of my abstract, complete with thesis 2.0.  Have a read through if you will and please provide any suggestions, constructive (or destructive) criticism, and get blogging everyone.

Thesis:  Can biomimetic mutualism be applied to the development of the built environment for the benefit of existing and future structures?

Mutualism as defined by Merriam Webster is a: “beneficial association between different kinds of organisms.”  Examples of mutualistic relationships in nature are abundant and, by definition, successful for the parties involved.  Such associations can provide a new perspective through architectural theory as to how we relate buildings to each other.   

Much research has been done on the concept of parasitic buildings – additions of sorts that leech energy and resources off their hosts.  Proposed, is rethinking how architecture connects buildings and how “mutualism and its advocating of the both/and instead of the either/or forces the architect to examine both aspects of architecture and to make a more informed decision that is a mediation between the interests of the two” or more entities of, specifically, the built environment is now more prominent than ever (Workman 2004).  In employing such methodology, advancements in sustainability, retention/rejuvenation of existing buildings and newly inspired architecture will emerge.

Identifying examples of how nature solves issues through mutualism and how such solutions could be applied to the built environment is the primary objective.  The intention is to add additional space to an existing structure(s), while working within the framework of mutualism and the confines of local regulations to produce a design that not only allows for new structure(s) but also provides some benefits to the existing buildings.  Designs displaying how concepts of mutualistic biomimetics are employed is one manner of conveying the research.  Examining the potential methods to make use of mutualistic architecture is also of great benefit for future projects.  Such things as structure, aesthetics, and space can all be addressed – whether they are in regards to the existing structure or any new construction project.

As the concepts of mutualism will be heavily influenced from nature it is important to make the connection that such mutualistic relationships occur in nature to ensure that the participants survive, as well as thrive in some conditions.  This relates directly to the sustainability aspect of this research.  “If a building can continue to function effectively for an indefinite period, it is considered sustainable” and such results can be achieved through a mutualistic approach to building design (Douglas 461).  Furthermore, mutualism can aid in a building’s lifespan and thus sustainability.

Although firmly rooted in precedence in other fields, mutualism can be a foundation for architecture and building development in the future.

Sketch #1

Working through some ideas I figured I would gun out some sketches of some heritage buildings in Kamloops with some basic additions.  Here's one, currently the BDC building on Victoria and 2nd.

I think most likely my potential project will be going vertical (but things can always change).  As I have noted in one of previous posts, I think there are multiple potential benefits to addressing roof design on existing structures.  No real identifiable mutualism to speak of beyond additive roof features, overhanging on all sides to protect the building below.  There is potential for structure to be added from the building above down the exterior between the windows and doors.  However the Frieze at the top of the buildings could pose some issues to navigate around.  It should be noted my intent is to maintain the features of the existing buildings I study as much as possible, not altering them too much with proposed mutual partners.

W

Potential Thesis

Working on focusing my topic for our abstract submission.  So, here is the thesis I am proposing... for now.  I am sure things will change over the course of the next little while; as such, any comments would be greatly appreciated.

When examining buildings' relationships with one another, is it possible to employ biomimetic mutualism to aid in the development and sustainability of the built environment?

The goal is to take some examples of how living creatures interact with each other in ways that benefit all the participants and see how that could be applied to buildings to better their performance and efficiency.  Seemingly straight forward but at the same time it is becoming quite difficult to focus in on the specifics.  Much has been written in regards to building adaptation and evolution which I am sifting through at the moment - all of which is contributing to the "Information Inundation" (little term we coined last semester for one of our term projects).

Anyways, hope everyone else is rattling through their research alright and generating some good ideas.

W